Politecnico di Torino (logo)

Cacciapaglia, Marzia

Exchanging good practices of environmental sustainability : the image approach.

Rel. Umberto Janin Rivolin, Nadia Caruso. Politecnico di Torino, Corso di laurea magistrale in Pianificazione territoriale, urbanistica e paesaggistico-ambientale, 2014


Nowadays, where even the simplest and daily actions to be carried out need an energy supply, it is unthinkable not to dwell on energy issues and considering the strong impact that these have on the environment. Talking therefore of energy efficiency means to evaluate all possible alternative methods and technologies of energy production with the aim of reducing consumption and consequently prices, thus making production/consumption relationship efficient and effective and ensuring the sustainability of the whole process from the environmental point of view. The efficiency is ensured through a conscious and responsible use of sources. Unfortunately, in recent times the use of sources was not performed in a conscious and responsible way, so much so that today we talk about exhaustion of fossil fuels, the main source of energy, within 40 years or so. Considering this future perspective appears necessary to seek alternative energy sources that don’t endanger the environment. These aspects allow to introduce the topic on promoting the use of renewable energy sources, which, given their main feature, don’t run the risk of running out, that are able to regenerate themselves at the same speed in which they are used, and especially don’t pollute and don’t have an impact on environmental sustainability. In addition the contribution of energy efficiency, in different economic sectors, not only is the key to reducing dependence on exporting countries of primary energy sources, but also it limits the exposure to the instability of prices and risk in the supply of energy. Another important feature it’s its role, recognized in national and European level, in which efforts can be spent for the reduction of CO2 emissions, in line with the international commitments to combat climate change and environmental sustainability.

The thesis develops the theme of environmental sustainability, focusing in particular on the role that energy plays in this context. The three main concepts that have allowed the relationship between the two issues are energy efficiency, use of renewable energy sources and the reduction of CO2 emissions, issues at the heart of the European debate.

These concepts constitute the overall theme of the thesis, which has been developed from the experience of internship, done at the research department of Hafen City University of Hamburg (GE), which is the academic partner of the European initiative “IMAGINE low energy cities”. The initiative has the specific aim to help cities, stakeholders and citizens to think, evaluate and accept the changes necessary from the point of view of energy to ensure environmental sustainability. In Particular, IMAGINE focuses on inspiring change and developing the concept of “low-energy city with a high quality of life for all” in order to contribute to inspiring the reflections and strategies of social, institutional and economic players at all levels. As well, IMAGINE intends to contribute to the success of the Covenant of Mayors, encouraging local authorities to define long-term visions. In this regard, has provided to the eight cities a grid to be filled out, which has allowed these to develop an analysis regarding the specific governance information and energy sectors.

During the internship in fact, the aim was to think a method to evaluate the quality of the grids compiled from partner cities. The individuated method allows an easy reading of the tables and provides for the development of the overall results.

mes introduced and the internship, the objec concerns the assessment of the progress made to daield, of the uate in energy projects as IMAGINE, of benefild draw and the elaboration of some recommendations/s to the itself and to keep up with the times.

Ting developed primarily by deepening the themes oftainabconsidering the European targets, analyzing tment of the EU in this context, noting in particulard analysis undertaken for the IMAGINE initiative and then using Torino and its Atainable Energy (TAPE) as a assessment of the plan, similarto that used in IMAGINE, and providing recommendations to the city to improve its performance in the field of energy . This will assess the effectiveness of IMAGINE and its chance to become a good practice to follow.

The subject of the thesis, in particular, has been developed and articulated from two major issues, environmental sustainability and energy issues (Chapter 2) and the concept of exchange of good practices (Chapter 3). The unifying element between the two themes is represented by the role that the EU plays in this context and by the European IMAGINE initiative, the subject of chapter 4.

In fact, once described the nature of the problem in relation to the European energy major theme of environmental sustainability and understood the concept of good practice and its exchange, is introduced the European IMAGINE initiative, conceived as a possible good practice by its nature of platform exchange of ideas, information, promotion and encouraging the development of actions for the energy shift. Here are also described and introduced the analyzes carried out in the internship experience for the eight European cities participating, by which develops the discourse on participation and the benefits that the initiative may involve.

Chapter 5 therefore focuses on the case study of the City of Turin, offers a description of the context and the plan that has been chosen to analyze, indicating the reasons and the methodology used for the evaluation. This chapter concludes with some final considerations by which are developed some recommendations to provide to the city to continuously innovate and improve itself on energy and on the environment field.

In other words, the analysis above described, has the purpose to provide the City of Turin, a new key of lecture and a real tool to be apprehended as an opportunity for development and change, IMAGINE objectives.

Relatori: Umberto Janin Rivolin, Nadia Caruso
Soggetti: S Scienze e Scienze Applicate > SE Ecologia
Corso di laurea: Corso di laurea magistrale in Pianificazione territoriale, urbanistica e paesaggistico-ambientale
URI: http://webthesis.biblio.polito.it/id/eprint/3925

1. Introduction

2. The environmental sustainability

2.1 A dimension of the environmental sustainability

2.2 The European aims

2.2.1 Aims for 2020

2.2.2 The target for 2030

2.2.3 Towards the Road Map 2050

3. Exchanging good practices in Europe

3.1 Concept and characteristics

3.2 EU: an exchange platform of good practices

3.2.1 Programming, influences and transposition

3.3 Transfer of good practices

4. The “IMAGINE” initiative

4.1 Interreg IVc programme

4.2 The initiative

4.2.1 The local level and the long term vision

4.2.2 The backcasting method

4.2.3 The local energy road map 2050

4.3 Method of analysis of the current state

4.3.1 The structure

4.3.2 Method of the “Traffic Light System”

4.3.3 The assessment and elaborate

4.4 Outcomes

5. Application on Turin Action Plan for Energy

5.1 TAPE general indications

5.2 Action Plan structure: sectors and actions

5.3 Turin, a low energy city?

5.4 Possible recommendations

6. Conclusion

7. References

8. Annexes


-Agency for work and education, strumentai body of the Campania Region (2006) “Attività di ricerca su “Studi e analisi sulle modalità di trasferimento delle buone prassi e dei modelli esemplari per la formazione” Misura 3.5 k POR Campania 2000-2006”, Campania (IT) http://www.lavorocampania.it/ARLAS/resources/cms/ documents/Volume Arlav-07.pdf

-American college & university - Presidents Climate Commitment(2007) “A Call for Climate Leadership-Progress and Opportunities in Addressing the Defining Challenge of our Time”, USA http://www.presidentsclimatecommitment.org/pdf/ climateleadership.pdf

-Ardito G., Bobbio D., Leonardi M. (2012) “Obiettivo 2050: Per una Road Map Energetica al 2050 Rinnovabili, efficienza,decarbonizzazione”, Rapporto REF-E per WWF Italia http://awsassets.wwfit.panda.org/downloads/obiettivo2050reportwwf. pdf

-Cambridge Econometrics (2013) “Employement Effects of selected scenarios from the Energy roadmap 2050, Final report for the European Commission (DG Energy)”, Cambridge(UK) http://ec.europa.eu/enerav/observatorv/studies/doc/2013report employmenteffectsroadmap 2050.pdf

-Carbone C. (2006) “De Simone: Come creare un sistema di buone pratiche”, num. 99, pp.13 http://archivio.denaro.it/VisArticolo.aspx?ldArt=435638&KevW

-City of Turin (2010) “TAPE-Turin Action Plan for Energy”, Turin http://mvcovenant. eumavors.eu/docs/seap/269 1322229105.pdf

-Commission of the European Communities (2013) “Climate Action”, The policies of European Union, Bruxelles http://europa.eu/pol/index it.htm

-Commission of the European Communities-Directorate-General for Research and Innovation (2011) “Green Paper on a Common Strategic Framework for EU Reseach and Innovation Funding-Analysis of public consultation”, Luxembourg http://ec.europa.eu/research/csfri/pdf/consultation-conference/summarv analysis, pdf

-Commission of the European Communities-The EU Framework Programme for Research & Innovation (2014) “Florizon 2020 in brief, Luxembourg http://ec.europa. eu/proqrammes/horizon2020/en/news/horizon-2020-brief-eu-framework-proaramme-research-innovation

-Coordination of local Italian Agenda 21 (2010) “Gli Impegni delle Città e dei Territori d’Italia per il Clima-Buone pratiche di Enti Locali e Regioni per la mitigazione e l’adattamento ai cambiamenti climatici”, second edition, Modena(IT) http://servizi.comune.fe.it/attach/aaenda21/docs/it brochure coord 2010def.pdf

-Cotella, G. & Janin Rivolin, U. (2010) Institutions, discourse and practices: towards a multidimensional understanding of EU territorial governance, paper presented at the XXIV AESOP Congress Space is Luxury, Helsinki, 7-10 July.

-Department of Management Engineering of Milano Politecnico and the Foundation Study Center Enel(2013) “Stato e prospettive dell’efficienza energetica in Italia”, report 1/2013 http://www.enel.com/it-IT/doc/enel foundation/librarv/report/ef reoortl.2013.pdf

-Disint C., Michelini M. (2005) “Dalle cattive alle buone pratiche per l’orientamento: idee ed esperienze”, Magellano VI, 27, research article, Udine (IT) http://www.fisica. uniud.it/URDF/laurea/idifo1/materiali/a10 c12/16-R2 CattiveBuonePratiche2.pdf

-Energy Cities (2011) “Challenges for the city-A local IMAGINE process” http://doc2.energ-cities.eu/greenstone/collect/imagine/index/assoc/HASH29d5.dir/lmagineToolboxChallenaesEn.pdf

-Energy Cities (2011) “Exercises, tools and methods-A local IMAGINE process” http://doc2.enerav-cities.eu/greenstone/collect/imagine/index/assoc/HASH0115.dir/ lmagineToolboxMethodesEn.pdf

-Europarlamento24 E People (2013) “Energia: la road map 2050 si guadagna il sostegno di Strasburgo”, in: Il Sole 24 Ore http://www.europarlamento24.eu/eneraia-la-roadmap-2050-si-quadaqna-il-sosteqno-di-strasburgo/0,1254.106 ART 2378.00. html

-European association of local authorities in energy transition (2014) “Omnipresence of energy: tap the potential of EU’s territories Energy Cities address EU politicalleaders”, Bruxelles, http://www.enerav-cities.eu/IMG/pdf/resolutionbxl2014finalen.pdf

-European Commission(2001) COM (2001)164 “A Sustainable Europe for a Better World: A European Union Strategy for Sustainable Development” htto://eur-lex. europa.eu/leaal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:52001DC0264&from=EN

-European Commission (2010) COM(2010)639 “Energy 2020-A strategy for competitive, sustainable and secure energy”, Brussels http://eur-lex.europa. eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=COM:2010:0639:FIN:EN:PDF

-European Commission(2011 a) COM(2Q11)885/2 “ Energy Roadmap 2050”, Brussels http://ec.euroDa.eu/enerav/enerav2020/roadmaD/doc/com 2011 8852 en.pdf

-European Commission(2011 b) COM(2011)112 “A Roadmap for moving to a competitive low carbon economy in 2050”, Bruxelles http://eur-lex.europa. eu/l_exUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=COM:2011:0112:FIN:it:PDF

-European Commission(2012) “The European Union Explained-Energy”, Brussels


-European Commission(2013) COM(2013)169 “Green Paper, A 2030 framework for climate and energy policies”, Bruxelles http://ec.europa.eu/enerav/consultations/doc/ com 20130169greenpaper 2030en.pdf

-European Commission(2014 a) “INTERREG IVc - Annual Implementation Report 2013” http://www.interrea4c.eu/proaramme

-European Commission(2014 b) “Press Release-2030 climate and energy goals for a competitive, secure and low-carbon EU economy”, Brussels http://europa.eu/rapid/ press-release IP-14-54 en.htm

-European Commission, General Directorate for Energy (2011) “Energy 2020-A strategy for competitive, sustainable and secure energy”, Luxembourg http://ec.europa.eu/enerav/publications/doc/2011 enerav2020 en.pdf

-European Commission, General Directorate for Energy-Market Observatory for Energy (2011) “Key Figures” http://ec.europa.euhttp://ec.europa.eu/enerov/observatorv/countries/doc/kev fiaures.pdf

-European Commission, General Directorate for Enterprise, Innovation Directorate, Communication and Awareness Unit (2001), “Innovation & Technology Transfer 5/01, exchange of good practices”, online magazine, Bruxelles http://cordis.europa.eu/itt/itt-en/home.html ì

-European Parliament and Council (2012) Directive 2012/27/UE, in Energy Efficiencvhttp://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?un=QJ:L:2012:315:0001:0056:IT:PDF

-European Union, Interreg IVc, “INTERRG IVC Frequently Asked questions” INTERREG IVC Freguentlv Asked Questions

-FORMEZ- training center and studies (2003) “Governance and Territorial Development, Azioni di sistema per la pubblica amministrazione” volume 11, Roma (IT) http://biblioteca.formez.it/webif/media/ASPA 11.pdf

-Foundation for Community Association Research (2014) “Best Practices, Report #7 Transition” Reports of good practices, USA http://www.cairf.org/research/ bptransition.pdf

-Hafner M.,(2011) “Transition to words a Low Carbon Energy System by 2050:What role for the EU?” Final report of THINK project, Topic3 http://www.eui.eu/Proiects/THINK/Documents/THINK2050Report.pdf

-Herring H. (2006) “ Energy efficiency-a critical view”, Energy 31, pp. 10-20

International Institute for Sustainable Development, Brundtland Report https://www. ¡isd.org/sd/

-ISOFOL- Community intervention area (2004) “Analisi dell’attuazione dei progetti di Trasferimento delle Buone Pratiche” Notice 1/2001 of PON System Actions and Notice 5/2001 of Measure II of PON ATAS FSE http://www.0cs.p0lit0.it/alpcitvru0/en/ dwd/lineeguida/6.1.pdf

-Jacobsson S. and BergekA. (2004) “Transforming the Energy Sector: The evolution of technological systems in renewable energy technology”, Industrial and corporate change, (13), No. 5, pp.815-849.

-National Structure of Support (SNS) of ISOFOL-Equal Community Initiative (2004)” Equal: Idee, esperienze e strumenti nelle buone pratiche dei Parternariati di Sviluppo”, Roma (IT) http://www.reaione.piemonte.it/archivio/lavoro old/equal/dwd/ buone pratiche.pdf

-ONU, United Nations Conference on Environment and Development http:// it.wikipedia.ora/wiki/Summit della Terra (accessed on: 10/11/2014)

ONU, lnitiative:”Sustainable Energy for all” http://www.se4all.org/

-Policy Research Centre Transitions for Sustainable Development (2014) “Climate neutral city initiatives: wishful thinking or thoughtful wish?”, Research paper 7, Leuven(BE) https://steunpunttrado.be/documenten/papers/trado-research-paper-7-1.pdf

-Province of Turin(2012) “8° Rapporto Energia”, online report http://www.provincia.

torino.gov.it/ambiente/fìle-storaae/download/eneraia/pdf/proorammazione/8 rapo/ Ottavo Rapporto Energia ProvTorino.pdf

-Qualenergia.it (2014 a) “Obiettivi UE 2030: “Italia apre a target 30% efficienza energetica”, online article http://www.oualenergia.it/articoli/20140916-obiettivi-ue-2030-%E2%80%9Citalia-apre-taraet-30-efficienza-energetica%E2%80%9D

-Qualenergia.it (2014 b) “Obiettivo efficienza: UE sulla buona strada per il target 2020”, online article http://www.oualeneraia.it/articoli/20140620-obiettivo-efficienza-energetica-ue-sulla-buona-strada-per-il-target-2020

-RSC-Region for sustainable change (2011) “Realizzare un’economia low carbon Guida per le regioni europee”, Interreg IVc document http://www.rscproject. oro/docs/RSC BuildinoLowCarbonEconomy_IT-Dec2011.pdf

-Stati Generali della Green Economy (2013)” La road map per la green economy in Italia” Roma (IT) http://www.statigenerali.org/cms/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/Roadmap_Green-Economy_70_proposte.pdf

-Trees L. (2012) “How to transfer Internal Best Practices”, Research provided by APQC, the international resource for benchmarks and best practices http://www.apac.org/sites/default/files/files/How%20to%20Transfer%20lnternal%20Best%20 Practices

-United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (2011) “Climate neutral cities-How to make cities less energy and carbon intensive and more resilient to climatic challenges” Geneve (Switzerland) http://www.unece.org/fileadmin/DAM/hlm/documents/Publications/climate.neutral.cities e.pdf

-Visintin F.(2013)”Strategie e roadmap in materia energetica nell’UE ed in Italia ed i relativi strumenti finanziari- Progetto SMART ENERGY”, Pordenone(IT)

http://www. slideshare.net/SmartEnerQvProiect/ceta-strateQie-e-roadmap-in-materia-energetica

-Valentino P. (2014) “La road map del il governo per il semestre europeo: l’Italia non chiederà sconti”, in: Corriere della Sera, Roma(IT) http://www.dirittiglobali. it/2014/06/18/road-map-governo-per-semestre-europeo-litalia-non-chiedera-sconti/

Modifica (riservato agli operatori) Modifica (riservato agli operatori)