Politecnico di Torino (logo)

Modeling of adaptive panels to control sound scattering in large environments

Botto Poala, Matteo

Modeling of adaptive panels to control sound scattering in large environments.

Rel. Massimiliano Lo Turco, Ursula Zich, Arianna Astolfi, Louena Shtrepi, Stefano Mariani. Politecnico di Torino, Corso di laurea magistrale in Architettura Costruzione Città, 2016

Questa è la versione più aggiornata di questo documento.



The operation of conceiving structures or buildings for the humankind has always consisted in transferring an image or a vision into reality. The tool for the transfer is the drawing and the result is a static and stable object in time. There is a tension towards creating stable solutions, a bit because it is simpler to consider non-variant conditions but also because there is an impulse to create order. A plan to answer the needs once for all. The belief that a good proposal can solve the problems for a long time, indeed time and mutable conditions are not considered.

The reality however is different, time passes and everything around us is continuously changing, nothing is stable. Design static solutions is not sufficient anymore if it wants to reach high level of sustainability. It is necessary to consider time and changing in the design phase, designing a good solution is not enough, its evolution and adaptation in time have to be studied too.

The debate about architecture has introduced the idea of changing in different aspects: from the urban considerations to the building technological solutions till consider in the design process of a building even its demolition phase. The whole life cycle of a construction is taken into account. The concept of changing has entered in the practice and there is a strong effort to overcome the traditional resilience of cities, buildings, and construction.

To meet the mutable conditions of the environment a good behavior can be represented by the adaptation capacity, changing in fact it is not sufficient to achieve higher level of sustainability and ensure better performances. The change must be driven, it has to be envisioned and studied. The attention in the design phase thus should be wide from the object of the design to reach and understand the characteristics of the environment in which the object will be placed. The surrounding becomes part of the process and study's object. Adaptiveness is the result of the conjunct study of the object and of the environment considering all the possible relationships and interactions.

The aspects involved in a building design are many, from the environmental parameters related to the climate condition of the site to the destination of use of the building and the behavior of its users. To reach the higher level of efficiency and to obtain innovative buildings it is necessary to deep all these aspects and get to a performative solution that has to consider the possibility of changing and adaptiveness constantly meet at the best the requirements.

In this diesis, starting from these considerations, has been formulated a proposal of an adaptive structures applied in the acoustic field starting from the studies of some existing examples.

In chapter 1 is reported an analysis of the context: it starts from a brief consideration about the influence of the digital technologies in the practice of architecture that has caused the appearance of new visions and new attitudes towards the discipline. These led to the rise of the concepts of "Smart Cities" and "Smart Buildings" which has guided the research and development towards more efficient and technological solutions relying on the latest technologies available, both for the design task both for the construction phase. The proposal of adaptive and transformable structure to reach higher level of performance is a consequence of the new possibilities open by the technological advances and the strive for efficiency and sustainability of the latest years. This analysis has been conducted to properly collocate the work in the international debate and it is accompanied by a selection of case studies of adaptive structures applied in different fields. The chapter ends with a presentation of the expected work, defining clearly the acoustic application, and highlighting the different aspects and competences involved in the development of the study. These wide from the geometry considerations, to the model and prototype issues to test and evaluate the solutions to the sound considerations for an effective application of the structure. For the complexity and variety of discipline implied it is reported also the organization of the work and the succession of design phases.

The chapter 2 contains the theoretical knowledge of the different disciplines that have been involved in this work. The geometric issues to identify a suitable shape for the application have been faced relying on the study of the origami that have already been used for engineer applications. The control of a variable geometry has required the use of algorithmic models which ensure fast changes and free control on the model. These aspects and the advantages coming from these tools are reported in the paragraph about computational design. The last paragraph of this chapter reports the base acoustic concepts to better understand the field of application and to introduce the specific aspect which the solution has to control that is the scattering coefficient.

Chapter 3 contains all the design development of the solution which starts from the firsts geometric considerations followed by the prototyping and assessment of the selected options. This has led to the identification of one suitable shape for an adaptive panel that has been tested performing the acoustic measurements in a reverberant chamber. The results obtained in laboratory have been used to perform an acoustic simulation of the application of the proposed solution inside the aula magna of the Politecnico di Torino. The results of the measurements and of the simulation are reported in this chapter.

In the conclusion is reported a summary of the results and the considerations coming from this experience. A brief analysis of the possible future developments is present too.

Relatori: Massimiliano Lo Turco, Ursula Zich, Arianna Astolfi, Louena Shtrepi, Stefano Mariani
Tipo di pubblicazione: A stampa
Soggetti: S Scienze e Scienze Applicate > SA Acustica
T Tecnica e tecnologia delle costruzioni > TE Tecnologia dei materiali
Corso di laurea: Corso di laurea magistrale in Architettura Costruzione Città
Classe di laurea: Nuovo ordinamento > Laurea magistrale > LM-04 - ARCHITETTURA E INGEGNERIA EDILE-ARCHITETTURA
Aziende collaboratrici: Politecnico di Milano
URI: http://webthesis.biblio.polito.it/id/eprint/4990



Chapter 1

Problem Framing

1.1.Context frame and precedents

1.2.State of the art: examples and references

1.2.1.SDU - Campus Kolding

1.2.2.Al Bahr Towers

1.2.3.Structure Investigations

1.2.4.Origami Office Building

1.2.5.Theme Pavillion EXPOYeosu

1.2.6.Resonant Chamber

1.2.7.Acoustical Dome

1.2.8.Manufacturing Parametric Acoustic Surfaces

1.3.Problem Statement

1.4.Work Strategy and Required Competences

Chapter 2

Theoretical Basis

2.1 Origami

2.1.1.History: from the origin to present day

2.1.2.Mathematic Fundamentals

2.1.3.Origami Classification

2.1.4.Rigid Thick Origami


2.2.Computational Design

2.2.1.Design tools and practice

2.2.2.Parametric Design

2.2.3.Algorithmic Design

2.2.4.Digital Manufacturing


2.3.1.Acoustic Concepts

2.3.2.Acoustic of Large Spaces

2.3.3.Scattering and Diffusion Coefficients

2.3.4.Measurement method of scattering coefficient

Chapter 3

Design Development

3.1.Preliminary Research and concept definition

3.1.1.Requirement Statement

3.2.Geometry Selection

3.2.1.Geometry Exploration

3.2.2.Geometry Tests and Assessment

3.2.3.Geometry Description

3.3.Acoustic Application

3.4.Models and Prototypes

3.4.1.Physical Prototypes

3.4.2.Geometry Description

3.5.Acoustic Measurements

3.5.1.Reverberant Chamber Characteristics

3.5.2.Measurements Results and Analysis

3.6.Application in an Existing Room

3.6.1.Case Study and Measurement Setup

3.6.2.Results and Comments





De Silva S., Dias P., Intelligent building for intelligentpeopk - a concept, ICSBE, 2010.

Beghini L.L., Beghini A., Katz N., Baker WF., Paulino G.H., Connecting architecture and engineering through structural topology optimisation, Engineering Structures 59 (2014) 716- 726.

Addington, Schdoek D.L. Smart Materilas and New Technologies: for the Architecture and Design profession, Elsevier 2005.

Nguye V., Syaifuddin M., Park H.C., Byun D.Y., Goo N.S., Yoon K.JL, Characteristics of an Insect-mimicking Flapping System Actuated by a Unimorph Pie^oceramic Actuator, J. of Intelligent Materia! Systems and Structures, vol. 19, 2008.

Pellegrino S., Deployable Structure, Wien: Springier Verlan Wien, 2001.

Chen Y., YouZ., Motion Structures: deployable structural assemblies and mechanisms, Spon Press 2012.

Kobayhashi H., Horikawa K., Monta Y., Unfolding of potato flower as a deployable structure, in Proceeding of the 6th International conference on Computation of Shell and Spatial Structure, IASS-LACM 2008.

Peraza-Hernandez E.A., Hartl D.J., Malak Jr R.J., Lagoudas D.C., Origami-inspired active strucutres: a synthesis and remew, Smart Mater. Struct. 23, 2014

Furuya H., Satou Y., Inoue Y, Masouka T., Microstrucutre of Foldable Membrane for Gossamer Spacecrafts, in Proceeding of the 6th International conference on Computation of Shell and Spatial Structure, IASS-LACM 2008.

Peters B., Acoustic Performance as a Design driver: Sound Simulation and Parametric Modeling using SmartGeometry, int. Journal of Architectural computing, vol. 8.

Jeon J.Y., Lee S.C., Vorlander M., Development of scattering surfacesfor concert halts, Applied Acoustics 65, 2004.

Alice G., Crovella D., Origami dalla tradizione alla contemporaneità, in Origami spirito di Carta cap.l, edizioni Yoshin Ryu, 2014.

Hatori K., History of Origami in the East and the West before Interfusion, in Origami 5: Fifth International Meeting of Origami Science, Mathematics, and Education. CRC Press, 2011.

Kasem A., Ghourabi F., Ida 'V.,Origami axioms and circle extension, Proceedings of the 2011 ACM Symposium on Applied Computing. ACM, 2011.

Tachi T., Simulation of Rigid Origami, Origami 4 American Mathematical Society, 2009.

Mitani J., Uehara R., Polygons Folding to Plurallncongruent Orthogonal Boxes, in Proceedings of the 20th Annual Canadian Conference on Computational Geometry, 2008.

Gretter R., Cenni storici, regole base, tipologie di Origami, in Origami spirito di Carta cap.l, edizioni Yoshin Ryu, 2014.

Bowen L.A., Grams C.L., Magleby S.P, Howell L.L., Lang R.J., A Classification of Action Origami as Systems of SphericalMechanisms )outtiai of Mechanical design 135:11 (2013).

Tachi T., Freeform Rigid-Foldable Structure using Bidirectionally Flat-Foldable Planar Quadrilateral Mesh, Advances in architectural geometry 2010.

Tachi T., Geometric considerations for the design of Rigid Origami Structures, Proceedings of the International Association for Shell and Spatial Structures (IASS) Symposium. Vol. 12. 2010.

Edmonson B.J., Lang R.J., Morgan M.R., Magleby S.P., Howell L.L., Thick rigidly foldable structures realise by an offset panel technique, Origami 6, American Mathematical Society, vol. 1, 2015.

Akitaya H.A., Mitani J., Kanamori Y., Fukui Y., Unfolding Simple Folds from Crease Patterns, Origami 6, American Mathematical Society, vol. 1, 2015.

Uehara R., A Survey and Recent Results about Common Developments of Two or More Boxes, Origami 6, American Mathematical Society, vol. 1, 2015.

Ho J., You Z., Thin-Walled Deployable Grid Structures, Origami 6, American Mathematical Society, vol. 2, 2015.

Maleczek R., Deployable Linear Folded Stripe Structures, Origami 6, American Mathematical Society, vol. 2, 2015.

D'Acunto P., Castellon Gonzalez J.J., Folding Augmented: A Design Method to Integrate Structural Folding in Architecture, Origami 6, American Mathematical Society, vol. 2, 2015.

Lubiw A., O'Rourke J., When Can a Polygon Fold to a Polytope?, Technical Report 048, Dept, of Computer Science, Smith College, Northampton, MA, 1996.

Abel Z., Demaine E.D., Demaine M.L., Matsui H., Rote G., Uehara., Common Developments of Several Orthogonal Boxes in Proceedings of the 23rd Annual Canadian Conference on Computational Geometry, 2011.

Applied Origami, Ingenia, n. 61 December 2014.

Lang R.J., The science of Origami, Physics World, February 2007.

Ishida S., Morimura H., Hagiwara I., Sound-Insulating Performance of Origami_based Sandwich Trusscore Panels Origami 6, American Mathematical Society, vol. 2, 2015.

Peters B., Computation works: the building of algorithmic thought, Architectural design, 2013.

Kolarevic B., Peters B., & Peters T., Parametric "Evolution, Inside Smartgeometry: Expanding die Architectural Possibilities of Computational Design, 2013

Dino I., Creative design exploration by parametric generative systems in architecture, METU Journal of Faculty of Architecture, 2012.

Hernandez C.R.B., Thinking parametric design: introdudng parametric Gaudi, Design Studies, 2006.

Reinhardt D., Cabrera D., Jung A., Watt R., Towards a Micro Design of Acoustic Surfaces, Robotic Fabrication in Architecture, Art and Design 2016, Springer International Publishing, 2016.

Bonwetsch T., Robotic Assembly Processes as a Driver in Architectural Design, in Digital Fabrication, Springer Basel, 2012.

Cox T.J., Dalenback B.I., DAntonio P., Embrechts J.J., Jeon J.Y, Mommertz E., & Vorländer M., A tutorial on scattering and diffusion coefficients for room acoustic surfaces, Acta Acustica united with ACUSTICA, 2006.

Vorländer M., Mommertz E., Definition and measurement of random-incidence scattering coefficients, Applied Acoustics, 2000.

Vorländer M., Embrechts J.J., De Geetere L., Vermeir G., de Avelar G., & Henrique M, Case studies in measurement of random incidence scattering coeffidents, Acta Acustica united with acustica, 2004.

Choi YJ., & Jeong D.U., Effects of unspedfied experimental conditions in ISO 17497-1 on the scattering coeffidents measured in a scale model, Acta Acustica united with Acustica, 2011.

Shtrepi L., Astolfi A., DAntonio G., Vannelli G., Barbato G., Mauro S., & Prato A., Accuracy of the random-incidence scattering coeffident measurement, Applied Acoustics, 2016.

Jeon J.Y, Lee S.C., & Vorländer M., Development of scattering surfacesfor concert halls, Applied acoustics, 2004.

Kim Y. H., Jang H. S., & Jeon J. Y., Characterising diffusive surfaces using scattering and diffusion coeffidents, Applied Acoustics, 2011.

Bibby C., Hodgson M., Characterisation and improvement of absorption and scattering by profiled architectural surfaces without specialised test facilities, Applied Acoustics, 2011.

Hargreaves T.J., Cox T.J., Lam Y.W, D'antonio P., Surface diffusion coefficients for room acoustics: free-field measures, J. Acoustic Society of America, 2000.

Tedeschi A., A AD Algorithms Aided Design, edizioni Le Penseur, 2014.























Modifica (riservato agli operatori) Modifica (riservato agli operatori)