Politecnico di Torino (logo)

Bonardo, Martina and Quaglia, Giulia

Hong Kong urban lab : explorations into city's density.

Rel. Mauro Berta, Marta Carla Bottero, Alessandra Oppio, Wallace Ping Hung Chang, Francesca Frassoldati. Politecnico di Torino, Corso di laurea magistrale in Architettura costruzione citta', 2015

Questa è la versione più aggiornata di questo documento.


Hong Kong urban environment is strongly characterized by super-density features, namely representing a problem In terms of liveability and space quality. This thesis elects the city as a research lab to inquire into urban density issue, both on a theoretical and strategical level. Indeed the argument is composed by two parts. The first one deals mainly with Hong Kong as urban entity, trying to analyze its features under different point of views; conversely the second one focuses on Kwun Tong district, an underdevelopment urban fragment that acts as micro-scale city mirror. The former section looks at understanding current urban circumstances and how the city became a super dense metropolis. Indeed, historical, geographical and political assumptions are explored in order to illustrate how they affected last centuries city’s development. In particular a research about real estate management clarifies land administration and market potentialities together with related social issues. On the other hand, latter chapters concentrate on design strategies able to cope with such reality. The effort involves an innovative evaluation process that aims at considering stakeholders position throughout a combination of tangible and intangible values. Indeed, the method foresees the application of project evaluation tools, that by ranking likely development scenarios, ensure transparency and consistency to the whole work, besides making the method transferable to other plausible situations. Finally the most performing alternative is developed in a strategical design proposal, according to desired architectural features pointed out by prior researches. Eventually Kwun Tong Marina Bay is the result of such process, and represents a likely development that tries to answer to density related concerns while coping with the complexity of a big scale urban regeneration.

Relatori: Mauro Berta, Marta Carla Bottero, Alessandra Oppio, Wallace Ping Hung Chang, Francesca Frassoldati
Soggetti: U Urbanistica > UK Pianificazione urbana
U Urbanistica > UL PVS Paesi in via di sviluppo
Corso di laurea: Corso di laurea magistrale in Architettura costruzione citta'
URI: http://webthesis.biblio.polito.it/id/eprint/4228


0.1 Rethoric of density

0.2 Density tools

1 Hong Kong borrowed time

1.1 Hiang Xiang, the unripe Hong hong

1.2 Migrations

1.3 One country, Two systems

2 A chorographic interpretation

2.1 Natural Landscape

2.2 Land reclamation

2.3 Anthropic setting

3 Technical answer

3.1 Legal system

3.2 Real estate

3.3 Strategies

4 Urban density dark sides

4.1 Susbsidized housing machine

4.2 At the top of the towers

4.3 Living in a cage

4.4 Social mobility SOCO

4.5 High rise and bach alleys

4.6 Public space

DOSSIER Kwun Tong marina Bay: Why?

5 Kwun Tong

5.1 Undergoing situation of a citY mirror.

5.2 A step bacK

5.3 SWOT

5.4 A vacant plot

6 Design method

6.1 Evaluation process. .

6.2 Step I: stakeholder analysis

6.3 Step 2: Scenario Building

6.4 Step 3: Questionnaires.

6.5 Step 4: NAIADE

6.6 Step 5- MAVT

7 Application

7.1 Stakeholder analysis...

7.2 Scenario Building

7.3 Questionnaires...

7.4 NAIADE qualitative evaluation

7.5 MAVT quantitive evaluation

8 Kwun Tong marina Baq

8.1 Strategy

8.2 Benefits

8.3 Social benefits


Final considerations


Density concerns


de Lauwe C., Antoine S., Bertin J. , Couvreur L., Gauthier J., Paris et l’agglomération parisienne, tome premier : L’Espace social dans une grande cité, PUF, Bib. de sociologie contemporaine, série B : Travaux du Centre d’études sociologiques, 1952, Paris


Pedersen S., One City, Nine Ghost Towns, http://popupcity.net/one-city-nine-ghost-towns/, last re¬trieved on 31/08/215

Somacon.com, Detroit Population History 1900-2000, http://www.somacon.com/p469.php. last re¬trieved on 31/08/2015

United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division (2011): World Popu¬lation Prospects. New York, http://esa.un.org/unpd/wpp/, last retrieved on 31/08/2015

Historical sources


Boston Med Surg, Climate and Diseases of China — Hong-Kong Fever, the New England Journal of Medicine, Boston, 1850

Cullen R., Hong Kong: the making of a modern state, 13eLaw J.24, 2006, Hong Kong

Dennys N. B., The treaty ports of China and Japan. A complete guide to the open ports of those countries, together with Peking, Yedo, Hongkong and Macao , ed; Mayers, William Frederick, 1831- 1878,London

Ku A., \mmigration Policies, Discourses, and the Politics of Local Belonging in Hong Kong (1950- 1980), Modern China, Vol. 30 No. 3, Sage Publications, 2000, Hong Kong

Pui-yin H., Becoming Hong Kong, Development History of Construction Industry, The Commercial Press, 2010, Hong Kong

Smith G., A narrative of an Exploratory Visit to Each of the Consular Cities of China, and to the Is¬lands of Hong Kong and Chusan, Zheng Wen Publishing Co., 1972 , Taipei

Legal references & evaluation tools


Bourne L., Project relationships and the stakeholder circle, RMIT University, 2005, Melbourne

Dente B., Policy decisions, Springer, 2014, Berlin

Chan E.H.W., Yung E. H.K., Is the development control legal framework conducive to a sustainable dense urban development in Hong Kong?, Hong Kong, Elsevier Science Ltd., 2003

Constitutional and Mainland Affairs Bureau, The Basic Law of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region of the People’s Republic of China, 1990, Hong Kong

Development Bureau, Lands Department, Buildings Department, Provision of public open space in private developments chapter 7, Audit Commision, Hong Kong, 2014

Langdon & Seah, Quarterst review, Hong Kong First Quarter 2012, Lanong Limited, 2012, Hong Kong Housing Authority, Houong Kong, 2014rty Law in Hong Kong, An Introductory Guide,ity Press, 2010, Hong Kong

Mhwu M., Dedication of La Publipartment, Hong Kong, 2003

Munda G., A NAIADor sustainability benchmarking, Int. J. Environmend Manag. 1/2, pp.65-78, 2006

Nissim R., Land Admintice in Hong Kong, second edition, Hong Kong University P008

Standing Committee of the National People’s Congress, Urban Real Estate Administration Law of the People's Republic of China, issued in 2007, effective from 2009

Renaud B., Pretorius F., Pasadilla B., Markets at work: Dynamic of the residential real estate market in Hong Kong, Hong Kong University, 1997, Hong Kong

Tang P.K., Hong Kong Property Review 2015, A review of the Hong Kong property market for the year 2014 with forecast of completions for 2015 and 2016, Hong Kong , Commissioner Rating and Valua¬tion Department, 2015

Wai-Chung Lai L., Chi-wing Lo D.,Leu H., Change in Use of Land, a practical guide to development in Hong Kong, Hong Kong University Press, 2010, Hong Kong

Wong Y., “One country, Two System" in Crisis, Hong Kong’s transformation since the handover, Lexingtong Books, 2008, Plymouth,United Kingdom


Application for Public Rental Housing, http://www.housingauthority.gov.hk/linear/en/about-us/policyfocus/policies-onpublichousing/ last retrieved on13/07/2015

Cheng E., Compensation and rehousing arrangements for Choi Yuen Tsuen villagers, Hong Kong, Press Releases, http:/ral/201002/24/P201002240235.htm, last retrieus and Statistics Department Hong Kong Special Administ analysed by District Council District 20N14B0100.pdf, last retrieved on 29/06/2015

Community Legal Information Centre, Landlord and Tenant, http://www.hkclic.org/en/topics/landlord_tenant/all.shtml, last retrieved on 29/06/2015

Degli Innocenti N., II lease cambia I’appeal deliacquisto, Finanza e Mercati, II Sole 24 Ore, 20 Febbraio 2010, http://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/finanza-e-mercati/2010-11-30/lease-cambia-appeal-acquisto-095848.shtml?uuid=AYOTYunC last retrieved on 26/06/2015

Deloitte J., Employment Densities Guide 2nd edition, Off PAT, 2010, https://www.gov.uk/govemment/publications/employmentdensities-guide, last retrieved on 30/08/2015

Department of Justice, Legal system in Hong Kong, http://www.doj.gov.hk/eng/legal/, last retrieved on 29/26/2015

Global Construction review, Hong Kong’s heritage challenge, http://www.globalconstructionreview.com/trends/hong-kongs-heritage-challenge/, last retrieved on 30/06/2015

Home Affairs Department, Licensing Bed space Apartments, http://www.had.gov.hk/en/public_services/licensing/bedspace.htm, last retrieved on 13/07/2015

Housing Department, Number of Applications and Average Waiting Time for Public Rental Housing, http://www.housingauthority.gov.hk/en/about-us/publicationsandstatistics/prh-applicationsaveragewaiting-time/ last retrieved on 13/07/2015

Housing Department, Policies on Public Housing, General Housing Policies, https://www.housingauthority.gov.hk/en/about-us/policy-focus/policies-on-public-housing/index.html, last retrieved on 30/06/2015

Joint Declaration of the Government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and the Government of the People’s Republic of China on the Question of Hong Kong, Annex III , www.legislation.gov.hk/..7CAP_2301_e_b5.pdf, last retrieved on 29/26/2015

Lands department, Tender Lot No.: New Kowloon Inland Lot No. 6312 more information on

http://www.landsd.gov.hk/en/news/anotice_nkil6312.htm, last retrieved on 30/06/2015

Lam C., LCQ8: Public open space in private developments, Press Releases, 2011,Hong Kong http://www.info.gov.hk/gia/general/201002/24/P201002240235.htm last retrieved on 30/06/2015

Rider Levett Bucknall, Quarterly Construction Cost Update, Hong Kong report March 2014, 2014, Hong Kong

Renaud B., Pretorius F., Pasadilla B., Markets at work: Dynamic of the residential real estate market in Hong Kong, Hong Kong University, 1997, Hong Kong

Sparkes P., Real Property Law and Procedure in the European Union - Annotated Draft Question¬naire, http://www.eui.eu/DepartmentsAndCentres/Law, last retrieved on 29/06/2015

The Land Registry, Current Monthly Statistics, http://www.landreg.gov.hk/en/monthly/monthly.htm, last retrieved on 29/06/2015

Hong Kong city concerns Bibliography

Aldous D., Greening South East Asian Capital Cities, 22nd IFPRA World Congress Hong Kong 15-18 November, 2010, Hong Kong City Hall, 2010, Hong Kong

Canhem S., Wu R., Portraits From Above, Peperoni Books /Mccm, 2010, Hong Kong

Dwyer D. J., Asian Urbanizations Hong Kong Casebook, Hong Kong University Press, 1971, Hong Kong

Lai C., Treating the Symptoms, a critical review of urban renewal in Hong Kong, Civic Exchange, 2010, Hong Kong

Lang LaSalle J., Broader Hong Kong, Commercial Space Master-plan Embraces CBD Development, Advance Commercial Issue, 2012, Hong Kong

Leung J Ng, Chun M., Ho Y., Buildings Department’s efforts to tackle the unauthorised building works problem, Audit Commission, Hong Kong, 2003

Shelton B., Karakiewwicz J., Kvan T., The making of Hong Kong, From Vertical to Volumetric, Rout- ledge, 2011, Abingdon-on-Thames

Shuen Sit V. F., Hong Kong: 160 Years of Development in Maps, Joint Publishing Co., 2010, Hong Kong


Airport authority Hong Kong, Out port, Our Future - Hong Kong international airport Master Plan 2030, http://info.threerunwaysystem.com/pdf/en/mp2030_full_en.pdflast retrieved on 16/06/2015

EKEO, Back alley project @Kowloon East, http://www.ekeo.gov.hk/en/quick_wins/Back_Alley/ in¬dex.html, last retrieved on 13/07/2015

HZMBS and related Hong Kong projects, Prview, http://www.hzmb.hk/eng/about_uniqueness.html , last retrieved on 16/06/2015

Office of the licensing authority, Bedspace apartments, http://www.hadla.gov.hk/en/bedspace/, last retrieved on 13/07/2015

Social indicators of Hong Kong, Number of persons living in cage housing, http://socialindicators.org.hk/en/indicators/housing/8.11, last retrieved on 13/07/2015

Society for Community Organization, http://www.soco.org.hk/project/project_ main_e.htm, last retrieved on 13/07/2015

Statutory Planning Portal at http://www1.ozp.tpb.gov.hk/gos/default.aspx? Last retrieved 17/08/2015

Tai-fai H. L., LCQ11: Subdivided flats, bedspace apartments and cubicle apartments, http://www.info.gov.hk/gia/general/201210/24/P201210240386.htm, last retrieved on 13/07/2015

Geography and Climate


Chan Y., Reclamation and pollution in Hong Kong with special reference to Victoria Harbour, The Uni¬versity of Hong Kong, 2000, Hong Kong

Shuen Sit V. F., Hong Kong: 160 Years of Development in Maps, Joint Publishing Co., 2010, Hong Kong

Wong O., Unease at planned reclamation projects in Hong Kong Urban planning experts are criti¬cal of government plans that fail to offer a sound vision and details on how such work will improve people’s lives, South China Morning Post, Monday, 29 April, 2013


Development Bureau, Taking forward studies on reclamation, http://www.devb.gov.hk/en/home/my_blog/indexJd_69.html, last retrieved on 16/06/2015

Hong Kong Observatory, The Government of the Hong special Administrative Region, http://www.hko.gov.hk/, last retrieved on 16/06/2015

Ratti C., One country two lungs, MIT Senseable City Lab, http://senseable.mit.edu/twolungs/, last retrieved on 16/06/2015

Van Keulen L., A Bridge Too Far: Bridge to China Threatens the Future of Hong Kong, http://theprotocity.com/a-bridge-too-far-hong-kong-bridge-to-china-threatens-the-future-of-hong-kong/, last retrieved on 16/06/2015

WWF Hong Kong, WWF’s position on “Enhancing Land Supply Strategy - Reclamation outside Victoria Harbour-a land supply option”, http://www.wwf.org.hk/en/whatwedo/conservation/marine/sos/?6203/WWFs-position-on-Enhancing-Land-Supply-Strategy--Reclamation-outside-Victoria-Harbour-a-land-supply-option, last retrieved on 16

Modifica (riservato agli operatori) Modifica (riservato agli operatori)